GSW: 2000 MEETING MINUTES

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1323rd Meeting, Wednesday, January 12, 2000, 

Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club.

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 8:01 PM.  The minutes of the 1322nd meeting were accepted as read.

Visitors consisted of Ward Sanford and Kurt Hinaman of the USGS Water Resources Division; Stan Mroczowski, USGS geochemist, Reston; and John Wormington. 

   A guest book was started to record the names of visitors.

   There were no new members.

   Cy Galvin invited members to a meeting of the Potomac Geophysical Society on January 20, at which he will give a presentation on “The Extreme Coastal Storm Affecting New York in December, 1992: Physical Damage, Social Response, and a Seismic Event.”

   President Hammarstrom introduced the new committees for the upcoming year.  There were no informal communications.

   Spatial Patterns Of Diagenesis During Geothermal Circulation In Carbonate Platforms, Alicia Wilson, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston:

   Dolomitization can affect the hydraulic properties of carbonate rocks and may play an important role in the geochemical evolution of basin pore fluids, but the origin of massive dolomite is not well understood.  Laboratory and field observations indicate that dolomitization is limited severely by kinetic processes at low temperatures, and researchers have suggested that geothermal convection of seawater deep in carbonate platforms could provide the necessary supply of magnesium for dolomitization at temperatures high enough to overcome kinetic limitations.  Quantitative reactive-transport simulations were presented that allow prediction of the rates and spatial patterns of dolomitization during geothermal convection.  Complete dolomitization in warm areas of a platform is predicted over 10 to 50 My, depending on the flow system.  Simulations suggest that dolomitization during geothermal convection could create calcium-rich fluids, and results are consistent with field observations of calcium-rich warm springs on the west coast of Florida.  This work also suggests that dolomitization of thin beds at Eniwetok Atoll might have formed during geothermal convection in association with a sharp permeability contrast at the base of the platform.

   Questions by Cy Galvin, Steve Shirey, Jane Hammarstrom,. Chris Neuzil, Nathalie Marchildon, and two unidentified.

            Electron Microprobe Dating Of Monazite, John M. Hanchar, Dept. of Geology, The George Washington University:

   There have been many advances over the past ten years using the electron microprobe to date geologic events using the mineral monazite [(Ce,La,Nd,Th)PO4]. Determining and improving the analytical precision of monazite analyses can be achieved by using long counting times per analysis, increasing the number of analyses, or both. Determining the accuracy of such measurements, however, is more problematic due to the fact that small inaccuracies in the Pb content measured with the electron microprobe can lead to large variations in the calculated age. In the speaker’s experience, the calculated ages are usually significantly older than ages determined using isotopic dating techniques on the same monazite grains.  He and co-workers have dated several monazite grains that are used as standards for the Sensitive High-Resolution Ion Microprobe II (SHRIMP II) geochronology laboratory at the Geological Survey of Canada with the electron microprobe, and monazite grains from a placer deposit from western North Carolina. These results, and ways to improve the accuracy of electron microprobe monazite analyses were discussed.

   Questions by Steve Shirey, Jane Hammarstrom, Mike Braun, Dallas Peck, and Cy Galvin.

   The 1999 Mid-Atlantic Drought: Lessons Learned And Looking Ahead, Robert Hirsch, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston, VA:

   Droughts represent an interface between science and public policy.  A drought is defined by its societal effects, not strictly in scientific terms.  It is not simply a climatic phenomenon.  The effect of a drought depends on the effect considered, its duration, and the area affected.  There are various types of drought: climatic droughts, agricultural droughts, ecological droughts, hydrologic droughts, water supply droughts, and political droughts.  The 1999 Mid-Atlantic drought was illustrated by the discharge of the Potomac River at Point of Rocks.  The summer of 1998 was very dry, with little recharge, thus leading to low river discharge continuing until January, 1999.  In 1999, low discharges occurred from July to early September, when the drought was broken by Hurricane Floyd.  Although the drought was severe, river discharge was still generally greater than during the 1965-66 drought.  Nonetheless, the Washington area was at real risk of running out of water.  The situation was addressed in part by political measures, such as restrictions on water use, and in part by releases from the Jennings Randolph Reservoir, which had been built for just such a situation.  Groundwater levels were similarly affected.  In Pennsylvania, levels were low throughout most of the state.  The Survey’s system for remote real-time monitoring of surface water and groundwater levels proved useful for following the progress of the drought.  A drought of this magnitude is expected to occur about once every 25 years, on the average. 

   Questions by E-an Zen (2), Jane Hammarstrom, Dallas Peck, Steve Shirey (2), Mark Anderson, and one unidentified.

   Attendance was 65.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:39 PM.

   Respectfully submitted,

   Mark McBride,  Meeting Secretary

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1325th (and 1324th) Meetings, Wednesday, February 9, 2000, Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club.

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 8:00 PM. 

   The 1324th meeting was originally scheduled for January 26, but the meeting on that date was cancelled because of a severe snowstorm.  A pre-meeting poll of various older and wiser members reached the consensus that today’s meeting was the 1324th meeting, only delayed.  However, by presidential fiat, it was declared to be the 1325th meeting.  Therefore, there was no 1324th meeting. 

   The minutes of the previous, or 1323rd, meeting were accepted as read.

   Visitors consisted of Terry Green, of the University of California, Riverside; Alan Pedder, of the Geological Survey of Canada; and Adam Johnson of the USGS. 

   New members were announced, after having been approved at the board meeting this afternoon.  They were:

Chip Groat – USGS

Amitava Gangopadhyay – University of Maryland PhD candidate

Kevin Marvel – American Astronomical Society

Tim Cohn – USGS

   Four announcements were made:

   The deaths of Howard Evans and Lou Walter were announced, and a moment of silence was observed.

   Brett Leslie announced the Annual Meeting of the Geological Engineering Society.  Dan Goldin, the administrator of NASA, has been invited to speak.

   Mark Zerniak asked members to inspect copies of the draft Chesapeake Bay Agreement, which are available at the back table. 

   …and a happy birthday was wished to Pete Stiefel.

   There were no informal communications.

   The meeting was a special Video Night, making use of the new video projection equipment in the Powell Auditorium.  Two formal presentations were made, the first using video for much of the presentation, the second consisting almost entirely of a video:

   Biogeochemical Influences on Methane Hydrate Formation and Stability, Richard Coffin, Naval Research Laboratory.

   Over the past fifteen years, methane hydrates have become recognized as an abundant energy reserve in the world coastal margin.  Methane hydrates form when methane becomes trapped within an ice crystalline structure under high pressure and low temperature.  In appearance, they are waxy white or yellow solids.  One m3 of gas hydrate can contain 164 m3 of methane.  They are very common in coastal areas. 

   The presence of the hydrates has initiated investigations of alternate energy, coastal stability, ocean carbon cycling, and global economy. The Naval Research Laboratory (NRL) has initiated a 5-year research program designed to study methane hydrates in the coastal ocean floor.  The Navy is interested in methane hydrates because of how their release affects the acoustical properties of sediments, and because of their effects on the geotechnical properties of sediments, which may endanger the stability of structures in or on the ocean floor.  Research at NRL integrates the Navy priorities with these international scientific and economic topics.

   This work was initiated, at NRL, with research cruises in the Gulf of Mexico and the Norwegian-Greenland Sea.  Submarine dives were conducted at both sites to provide visual observation of the biological active regions and specific sample acquisition.  Samples, including cores of methane hydrate deposits, are being analyzed to understand the biogeochemical influence on methane hydrate formation and stability.

   A video, taken on submarine dives in the Gulf of Mexico, showed three diverse sites; 1) a region with a large abundance of tube worms, 2) a brine pool that supports an active chemosynthetic mussel community, and 3) a sediment surface methane hydrate, at a temperature of 6° C, that is surrounded with an active biological community.  Data presented included preliminary carbon isotope analyses of carbon pools which suggest that the methane hydrates reflect a significant source of old (isotopically light) carbon from considerable depths. 

   Questions were by Steve Shirey, Steve Huebner, and Pete Stifel, an eastern shore farmer. 

   Geology Goes Hollywood, Dorothy Stout, National Science Foundation:

   In the words of the presenter:

   Geology Goes Hollywood arose out of a symposium at GSA Boston in 1993 examining "How the General Public Perceives Geology".  Various modes of access to geology by the general public were discussed during the session.  Speakers included Sorena Sorensen on Museums, Chet Raymo of the Boston Globe on newspapers, Don Hyndman of "Roadside Geology" books, etc. All were in honor of John Shelton and his contributions to visualization in geology. 

   My youngest daughter, Deborah Steller, is a TV producer.  We combined to present how the general public perceives geology through the movies by using clips from some 50 Hollywood movies.  Humphrey Bogart's explanation of how you read the river in The African Queen; Superman's explanation of the San Andreas Fault; how fossils are perceived in Jurassic Park and The French Lieutenant's Woman; the inside of the Earth as conveyed in Journey to the Center of the Earth as just a few examples.  Other movies include:  Way Down East, Terms of Endearment, The Piano, Showboat, Around the World in 80 Days, Gilda, Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom, Pink Panther, the James Bond movies, Titanic, The Shawshank Redemption, Krakatoa East of Java, The River, LA Story, Black Widow, Joe vs the Volcano, and others.

   Over the subsequent years we have had many requests to duplicate the video, but since copyright laws preclude that step, and because we are within the three minutes limit for extracted footage and not making a profit, we simply show the 25 minute video for educational purposes when asked. 

   Since in the last few years Hollywood has produced several movies with geoscience plots, we have revamped the video and updated it with clips from Dante's Peak (consultant Jack Lockwood of the USGS), Volcano (consultant Rick Hazlett at Pomona College), Asteroid Impact, Twister, etc. Most recently we have shown the video at the Denver GSA meeting, the University of Vermont, the National Science Foundation, and the USGS.  It is meant to be entertaining, yet drives home points about what can be learned and what is misconceived.

   There was one question by Nathalie Marchildon.

   Attendance was 62.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:27 PM.

   Respectfully Submitted,

   Mark McBride, Meeting Secretary

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1326th Meeting, Wednesday, March 8, 2000

Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club.

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 8:01 PM.  The minutes of the 1325th meeting were accepted as read.

   Visitors consisted of Fred Block, Office of Surface Mining; Pingwa Chow, China Institute of Mining Technology; Perle Dorr; and Bill Althoff, Air and Space Museum. 

   Five announcements were made:

   Gordon Nord requested judges for a number of science fairs.

   Bill Minarik pointed out that a large bedrock excavation was taking place in Georgetown; was anyone interested in trying to examine it, or did anyone have contacts that would help some one get in?

   Jeff Grossman announced that he has the last 20 years of GSW minutes on the web site.

   We can have 6 more delegates to AAPG: Who wants to be a delegate?

   Don’t park in the Cosmos Club lot and say that you are here for GSW!

   There were  no informal communications.

            Geology of the Golden Cross epithermal gold deposit, New Zealand, Jeffery Mauk, University of Auckland, New Zealand:

   Active geothermal systems in the Taupo Volcanic Zone provide invaluable analogues to help us understand the processes that form epithermal deposits.  The zone lies along the boundary between the Pacific and Australian Plates, which cuts through New Zealand.  It contains about 50 epithermal systems, both active and extinct. 

   The Golden Cross mine is a classic low sulfidation epithermal ore deposit in the Hauraki goldfield of New Zealand.  It was mined by open pit and underground methods from 1991 to 1998 and produced over 650,000 ounces of gold.  The host Miocene volcanic rocks have two main types of alteration that we interpret to have formed from two different fluid types.  The assemblage quartz, chlorite, adularia, replacement calcite, illite, illite-smectite (I-S), pyrite formed from dilute (<2 wt% NaCl equiv.) upwelling neutral chloride waters at temperatures ranging from over 140 to over 220°C.  Late calcite veins formed from descending CO2-rich, steam-heated water. 

   Detailed underground mapping has revealed that Golden Cross contains over eight generations of veins.  Most of the gold recovered from the underground workings was extracted from colloform banded quartz veins, which formed relatively early.  Structural analysis indicates that barren and mineralized veins formed in an extensional regime, and that the deposit underwent significant rotation after the underground veins formed.  Discovery of bedding dipping near 45 degrees now indicates that extension occurred when the present high-angle veins were close to vertical. 

   Questions: Jane Hammarstrom (2), Paul Barton, Mark Fratke, Amelia Logan.

            The Corps of Engineers Role in Abandoned Mine Restoration, Michael J. Klosterman, Chief Geologist, US Army Corps of Engineers, Washington DC:

   Recent legislation has given the US Army Corps of Engineers a role in the restoration of abandoned mine lands.  Issues include safety – eg entry to tunnels; abandoned hazardous wastes; tailings; acid mine drainage; and “scam” mining on public lands.  The nature of this role in presently evolving both through the development of internal Corps policy as well as through the legislative and appropriation processes in Congress.  A consortium of Corps district offices in the Western states has formed a group called RAMS (Remediation of Abandoned Mine Sites) to facilitate the use of Corps resources by other Federal and State agencies.  Major policy issues being resolved include: (1) proposals for a number of partnered demonstration projects; (2) development of an AML technology database; (3) developing partnerships with non-governmental organizations; (4) sharing responsibilities and costs with other Federal agencies, (5) reducing potential liability by focusing on ecosystem restoration of the entire watershed; (6) remediation of safety & health hazards; (7) streamlining the Corps planning process.  The Corps Headquarters' staff is presently preparing a position paper on an AML program for approval by Senior Management.

   Questions: Pete Toulmin, Moto Sato.

   Geochemistry of Acid Mine Drainage from the Abandoned Elizabeth Copper Mine, South Strafford, Vermont.  Robert R (Bob) Seal, II, US Geological Survey, Reston, VA

   The USGS, in cooperation with a local citizens group (the Elizabeth Mine Study Group), is characterizing acid mine drainage from the abandoned Elizabeth mine site to serve as the basis for potential future reclamation.  This site is close to being listed as a National Priorities List (Superfund) site.  Elizabeth is the largest stratiform, sediment-hosted (Besshi-type) massive sulfide deposit, dominated by pyrrhotite and chalcopyrite, in the Vermont Copper Belt of eastern Vermont.  Mining began in the late 18th century, ceased in 1958, and produced copper and zinc with minor gold and silver.  Open-pit and underground mining produced about 4 million tons of ore.  The remains of the mine have a high acid-generating potential, exacerbated by low carbonates in the host rock which result in low neutralization potential.  Copperas Brook drains the site and empties into the Ompompanoosuc River.  Effluent from the mine site is also delivered directly to banks of the river from underground workings.  Waters from the site can be divided into four groups: (1) water in the South Pit, (2) water draining from the mine workings, (3) surface waters draining the site, and (4) ground waters seeping from beneath waste piles.  Of these, the waters in the South Pit, those draining from the workings, and those seeping from beneath the waste piles, up to 100 feet high, remain fairly constant in volume and chemistry during the year, but surface waters vary seasonally.  The concentration of dissolved oxygen in all waters is near saturation, except for the ground water seeps.  Other salient features of the water chemistry are summarized below.

                      pH           SO4           Fe                 Cu                  Zn

                                     mg/L         mg/L             mg/L               mg/L

South Pit    3.7 - 4.5        92          0.043            0.011              0.005

Draining Mine Workings

                 5.1 - 6.0   550-560      45.7             0.040                 -

Ground Water Seeps

                 6.1 - 6.9   50-3,600  11.0-560    0.001-0.013   0.0006-17.0

Surface Waters

                 2.1 - 3.2  330-1,700 32.0-200       8.8-55.0        2.5 - 17.0

   The pH of the seep waters rapidly decreases downstream due to the oxidation and hydrolysis of iron species, such that Copperas Brook has a pH of ~2.7 prior to emptying into the river.  In the dry season, the acidity and heavy-metal content of surface waters can be dramatically increased through the dissolution of efflorescent salts such as melanterite and rozenite during storm events.  Of the heavy metals, only Cu, Zn, and Cd exceed U.S.E.P.A. guidelines for acute toxicity in freshwater aquatic ecosystems, consistent with the geochemical characteristics of the deposit.

   Studies at the mine reflect the USGS’s general shift from classical economic geology to mineral remediation studies.  Technically, this involves a shift of emphasis from high to low temperature geochemistry, and from equilibrium to disequilibrium condition.  There is now a greater need to intertact with numerous different groups with different agendas.

   Questions: Hal Gluskotter, Dan Milton, Pete Toulmin, Doug Rankin, and John Slack.

   President Hammarstrom announced that next week would be Federal Science Night.

   Attendance was 68.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:46 PM.

   Respectfully Submitted,

   Mark McBride, Meeting Secretary

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1327th Meeting, Wednesday, March 22, 2000, Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 7:59 PM. 

   The minutes of the 1326th meeting were accepted as read.

   Visitors consisted of John Brice, State Geologist of Nevada; Gretchen Onstad, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill; and Sandra Herbert, University of Maryland

   Two announcements were made:

   On May 13, Michael Wise of the Smithsonian will lead a field trip to the Moorfield Pegmatite in Virginia.

   We still need to elect five delegates to the AAPG; interested persons please see President Hammarstrom after the meeting.

   There were no informal communications.

   The meeting was significant in that all three speakers ran significantly over the customary 20 minutes.  Because of their eminence, no action was taken.

   Digital Earth: the Web-Wide-World  (26 minutes), Alan Gaines, National Science Foundation:

   The “Digital Earth” is a concept for a worldwide database that provides a browseable 3D representation of the earth. “Digital Earth will be a virtual representation of our planet that enables a person to explore and interact with the vast amounts of natural and cultural information gathered about the Earth.” (Consensus definition adopted at the Second Interagency Digital Earth Workshop [IDEW2], held 1999 September 22-23 at University of Maryland.)

   Conceptually, it is a distributed geolibrary of “metadata” – data about sources and archives of data – implemented through the internet and related technologies.  Its aim, to combine data for beneficial use, is broadly shared within the geoscience community.  A convergence of science and technologies, including the internet, satellite imagery, and the global positioning system, now makes such a system thinkable.  A prototype is now available through the World Wide Web at http://www.digitalearth.gov/.

   Earth is an integrated system of parts and interfaces.  We have tended to confine ourselves to one part, such as the lithosphere, but we need now to combine our perspectives and look at interactions among the parts.  The challenge, then, is to combine widely dispersed data, in various forms, to generate information, and from this, knowledge. 

   The hardest part is integrating the components of such a data system so they can interoperate.  These components include computer systems and software of many kinds.  But besides these narrowly technical problems, there is also the problem of finding where all the data is, that could become part of such a system.  Not enough attention has been paid to this issue. 

   Implementation of the Digital Earth is starting with an interagency group led by NOAA and includes also nongovernmental organizations such as the National Geographic Society.  A series of workshops is being planned to create guidelines for data integration, engage the earth sciences community, and identify and address technical and cultural barriers. 

   Questions: Mack Ross, Rama Kotra, and Jane Hammarstrom.

   Strategic Change at the USGS: What's In It for Science? (23 minutes), Chip Groat, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston:

   The USGS’s new director sees specific needs for the organization, in particular for the USGS to see itself as one organization, not four; and for the organization to have a single set of operating procedures.  In this vein, he has reorganized the Director’s office, given the Regions more responsibility, and added headquarters responsibilities to division (or more properly, discipline) chiefs.  The USGS is trying now to ask users what they need, and to focus its activities accordingly.  The focus is on raising the profile of the USGS with the public and the larger scientific community.

   But where is the science in all this?  Because of its organizational position, it is relatively hard for the USGS to become visible; it is not too well known on Capital Hill outside its “own” congressional committee.  The USGS does not have a customer base outside, e.g. in the universities (as is the case with the National Institutes of Health, for example), since so much of its work is done in-house.  Funding tends to be related to attention-getting issues such as floods and earthquakes.  Discipline-based studies will remain significant, but he sees the growth areas for USGS science in the areas of complex systems and the interfaces between systems., 

   Where is the USGS going in a strategic sense?  We can ask, where are the problems we will need to address?  To help identify these, he is giving the Associate Directors more responsibilities in identifying research focuses.  Dimensions that need to be added to the USGS’s vision include: How do we measure increased understanding of important elements?  How do we improve predictive abilities?  We need to think hard about where the USGS’s understanding and abilities should be focused. 

Strategic change along these lines must pay off in enabling USGS personnel to do science better, and to better apply their discoveries. 

   Questions:  Moto Sato, Rosalind Helz, Mack Ross, Brett Leslie, and Bruce Lipin.

   The Role of science in SCIENCE in the Voxellated 21st Century    (21.5 minutes), Nicholas B. Woodward, Department of Energy:

   An essential question today is what are the roles of scientific investigations and scientific data in developing and using large scale computational models for performance prediction and assessment in the coming century.  This is particularly important in the context of governmental bodies using these predictive models as the basis for policy formulations. The evolution of modeling in structural geology over the last century is taken as one way to understand the evolution of approaches and some of the pitfalls in the modeling business. It also suggests an answer to the question of roles.  Although computational models are outstanding new tools, and they enable us to do things we have never done before, they are never better than the quality of the questions asked of them, nor can they substitute for wise decision making using them as one, but not the only input.

   Attendance was 68.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:57 PM.

   Respectfully Submitted,

   Mark McBride, Meeting Secretary

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1328th Meeting, Wednesday, April 5, 2000

Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club.

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 8:00 PM. 

   The minutes of the 1327th meeting were accepted as read.

   Visitors consisted of Darrell Simms, SWRI. 

   Four announcements were made:

   A moment of silence was observed for two persons deceased.  Hal James, a former member, was formerly the Chief Geologist of the USGS.  Dr. I. Gregory Sohn was a member since 1947.  He spoke in 1966 and gave many informal communications. 

   According to Gordon Nord, judging of three science fairs has been carried out successfully, and one more will take place on April 8. 

   The field trip to the Moorfield Pegmatite Mine, Amelia, Virginia, will take place on Saturday, May 13.  Only 12 people will be able to go underground, but anyone can search surface tailings areas.  Contact Bill Burton for more information.

   Four new AAPG delegates have been selected.  They are Hal Gluskoter, Cy Galvin, Bob Burruss, and Suzanne Weedman. 

There were no informal communications.

            The Arctic as Miner's Canary for Global Warming, Michael Ledbetter , Office of Polar Programs, National Science Foundation:

   Global Circulation Models (GCMs) predict that the Arctic will feel the effects of Global Warming first and greatest due to the positive feedbacks resulting from loss of reflective ice and snow.  This feedback could produce rapid loss of most of the Arctic’s ice cover, with dramatic effects on world climate.  Reduction of the sea ice cover, especially, has a dramatic effect on predicted climate impact from Arctic warming.   Therefore the Arctic may act as the miner's canary for the rest of the globe to warn of impending Global Warming (either natural or anthropogenic).

   The past decade has seen a significant warming globally but more so in the Arctic.  Changes in environmental parameters such as glacial retreat, atmospheric temperature increases, reduced snowfall, thinning and retreating sea ice, tundra composition, and new migration routes of wildfowl, fish, and caribou have all been observed.  The environmental response to the recent warming provides a clear warning that the canary's health may be at risk.

   In order to improve GCM and other model simulations and predictions of Arctic climate and the environmental response, NSF and ONR are supporting the Surface Heat Budget of the Arctic (SHEBA) Ocean project.  SHEBA utilized the Canadian Coast Guard icebreaker Des Grolliers as a platform at which measurements of the physical parameters controlling sea-ice albedo and cloud-radiation feedbacks could be determined. The ship drifted over 1000 miles with the ice pack in the Beaufort and Chukchi Seas for one year in 1997-98 while researchers used submarines, satellites, an autonomous underwater vehicle, drifting buoys, aircraft, and instruments deployed on and through the ice to conduct the research program. The field data collected by SHEBA and two complementary projects supported by NASA and DoE at the SHEBA site are still being analyzed. 

   One of the unexpected results was the discovery in October, 1997 that a major melt season the previous summer had resulted in a normally three meter thick ice cover being reduced by 40%.  The loss of the ice nearly imperiled the selection of a site for the experiment.  While ice grew back during winter, a longer-than-normal melt season in 1998 left the ice pack thickness at only one meter at the end of the field experiment.   Considering the site had drifted over 100 miles further north during the year, which would have been expected to produce thicker ice near the site, could this be an important symptom leading to the canary's cough?  Researchers also have determined that some of the "standard" values used in GCMs varied significantly during the year so that an annual "average" is not representative of much of the year.  SHEBA is just about to enter the modeling phase of the project and more improvements in model simulations will follow the full digestion of over a terabyte of data.

   Questions: Cy Galvin, Mack Ross, and E-an Zen.

   Evidence of multiple asteroid impacts from Late Archean to Paleoproterozoic successions in Australia and South Africa. Bruce Simonson , Department of Geology, Oberlin College :

   A number of spherule layers have been found near the Archean-Protoerzoic boundary (ca. 2.5 Ga) in South Africa and Australia, where this boundary is best exposed.  These are probably strewn fields from large extraterrestrial impacts.  The spherule layers consist of spherical particles, a few millimeters in diameter.  In overall form, the spherules are unlike most (but not all) volcanic ejecta, but differ from them in detail.  Spherical volcanic ejecta are formed by the agglomeration of smaller particles, while the spherules in question are not.  Oolites are also superficially similar, but they exhibit outward growth for the center, while these spherulites show inward crystal growth.  They greatly resemble glassy spherules from the Eocene-age Chesapeake Bay crater. 

   The spherulite layers are on the order of 1 cm thick, and occur at exactly the same stratigraphic position over distances of approximately 300 km.  This is the right geometry for a strewn field.  An iridium anomaly was observed with the spherules from the Barberton banded iron formation, Australia.  At least five spherule layers occurred between 2.49 and 2.65 GA.  Often the layers show symmetrical lenses, which are interpreted as tsunami wave ripples.  Boulders of 1 m diameter are also found at the spherule level in the banded iron formation, which otherwise represents a very low-energy depositional environment. 

   The spherule layers appear to be thicker and to represent more basaltic material than similar layers in the Phanerozoic.  These may result form larger impactors, less extensive continental crust, or a generally shallower world ocean.

   Questions: George Helz, Jane Hammarstrom, Joe Smoot, Bill Burton, Dan Milton, Nita Sahai.

            How Algae Grow Shells of Glass: Silica Biomineralization by Diatoms, Nita Sahai , Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Maryland

   The study of biomineralization brings together geochemistry and biochemistry.  Biologically formed minerals are uniquely strong, among other things, so there is much interest in the processes by which they are formed.  Diatoms are a good example.  They are algae that secrete silica shells, and, in the process, help control geochemical cycling of silica, carbon, and phosphorus.  Biological components within the silica shells tend to be enriched in proteins and polysaccharides.  Silica may be polymerized to various degrees; NMR is a useful technique for studying this polymerization.  Issues being studied include: How is silica transported?  What kinds of bonds exist between silica and organic components?  Are proteins and polysaccharides involved in nucleation of silica?  Is nucleation catalyzed by enzymes?  What is the role of pentacoordinated silica? 

   Questions: Mack Ross, Bruce Simonson.

   Attendance was 45.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:56 PM.

   Respectfully Submitted,

   Mark McBride, Meeting Secretary

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1329th Meeting, Wednesday, April 19, 2000

Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 8:01 PM. 

   The minutes of the 1328th meeting were accepted as read.

   Visitors consisted of Henry Shaw, Lawrence Livermore Laboratory. 

   Five announcements were made:

   There were three new members: Fred Block, of the Office of Surface Mining; Anthony DeSouza, of the National Research Council; and Sandra Herbert, of the History Department of the University of Maryland, Baltimore.

   The field trip to the Moorfield Pegmatite is still scheduled for May 13.

   The Council has been discussing the possibility of a summer social cruise.  A show of hands showed about 15 people showing interest.  Watch the GSW web site for further details.

   Chip Groat, Director of the USGS, will be speaking tomorrow at the meeting of the Potomac Geophysical Society.

   Don’t park in the Cosmos Club parking lot and say that you are attending GSW!  The Cosmos Club will try to charge the parking to GSW if you do!

   There were no informal communications.  The recent lack of informal communications was officially noted, and President Hammarstrom asked members to get busy.

   There were, as usual, three talks:

            The aging of great escarpments - cosmic rays and geomorphology. Paul Bierman, University of Vermont:

   Our research addresses the erosional retreat of escarpments, for which there are several competing theories.  Examination of small-scale worldwide maps shows there are two kinds: arched (i.e. rounded) and shouldered (i.e. asymmetrical with a sharp crest).  Sinuousity of shouldered escarpments increases regularly with age, possibly because of restricted drainage areas.  Sinuousity of arched escarpments increases faster but less regularly with age. 

   To shed more light on these processes, the speaker visited the hyperarid Namib Desert, the Great Namibian escarpment, and the adjacent Namibian highlands of southwestern Africa where slow, steady erosion has occurred over Cenozoic times.  A principal tool was analysis of  10Be and 26Al. These isotopes are produced in situ by cosmic rays that penetrate mostly less than 3 m into the ground, and can therefore be used to determine erosional rates of surfaces. 

   Fifty-seven paired analyses of 10Be and 26Al in samples of bedrock primarily from inselbergs, of sediment from dry river and stream channels, and of quartz clasts from desert pavements reveal large inventories of these cosmogenic nuclides.  This implies significant landscape stability over the past million years.  Fission track data extend the erosion rate estimates back in time, suggest similarly low rates of landscape change, and imply that in general erosion rates have not changed significantly over >107 years.    

   Thirty-nine bedrock samples collected in three transects from the coast, across the escarpment, and into the highlands, show no spatial pattern in nuclide abundance despite a difference in mean annual precipitation between sample sites at the coast (<25 mm/year) and those in the highlands (>200 mm/year).  Average model erosion rates above the escarpment (3.4±1.7, n=6) are indistinguishable from average rates below the escarpment (3.6±1.9, n =33). Sediment samples (n=3) from small streams give similar results and suggest that a basin in the steep escarpment zone is eroding several times faster (16 m/My) than either a basin in the highlands (5 m/My) or a basin in the coastal plain (8 m/My).  Data from large rivers (n=3) constrain erosion rates, averaged over 105 years and 104 km2, between 7 and 9 m/My, consistent with rates estimated by fission track analysis.  Small quartz clasts (n=12) collected from four desert pavements record extraordinarily long, variable, and in some cases complex exposure histories.  Simple 10Be model ages are as high as 1.8 My; minimum total histories, considering both 10Be and 26Al and including both burial and exposure, exceed 2.7 My.  The pavement on which clasts have the highest nuclide abundance is located just at the base of the escarpment.  The pavement within the escarpment zone is least stable; all three clasts have indistinguishable exposure histories and isotopic data are consistent with steady erosion of the pavement at about 2 m/My.                 

   The similarity of erosion rates calculated from 10Be analysis of fluvial sediments and fission track analysis of rock suggests that steady state is a reasonable description of the Namibian landscape over large spatial and temporal scales.  At a smaller scale, it appears that the northern boundary of the massive Namib Sand Sea has been steady and unshifting.  At Gobabeb, just beyond the current extent of sand dunes, a transect of bedrock samples away from the dune field shows no isotopic history of burial, indicting that the dunes have not crossed the Kuiseb River for significant periods of time over the last 105 to 106 years.  At outcrop scales, the concordance of 10Be and 26Al in all bedrock samples suggests that the model of steady, uniform bedrock erosion is valid; there is no indication of burial or stripping of previous cover. 

   Earlier, King had proposed a classic model that the escarpment had retreated steadily and rapidly. Data from this study do not support this model; rather, the cosmogenic and fission track data suggest that the escarpment is retreating very slowly, if at all.

Questions: Chip Walker, Bill Jennings, E-an Zen, Moto Sato, and George Selden. 

            A new tool for sub-micron scale imaging and analysis of natural materials: focused ion beam microscopy. Ed Vincenzi, Smithsonian Institution:

   Focused ion beam microscopy (FIBM) is a new tool for examination of geological materials that has been derived from the microelectronics industry.  It has many features in common with scanning electron microscopy, but, instead of using electrons, uses a focused beam of gallium ions emitted by a tungsten filament.  Electrostatic rather than magnetic lenses are used because of the heavier ions, about 186,000 times heavier than electrons.  Each gallium ion has momentum about 356 times as great as that of an electron.  The beam can be used to excavate surface materials by “sputtering”, or else can deposit materials on the surface, for example metals used to dissipate local charges. 

   One application is cutting holes in specimens so we can look inside.  For example, we can cut a trench in surface and then polish its surfaces for examination.  We can also cut thin wafers, down to a thickness of about 100 nm, and remove them for examination by transmission electron microscopy.  The process is very controlled and observable, so wafers can be cut from precisely known geological contexts.  X-ray diffraction studies show minimal surface damage from this process.  The process is very fast; for example, transmission electron microscopy specimens of diamond can be obtained in about 2 hours rather than 2 weeks as required for other methods.

   FIBM has so far been found to be excellent for framework silicates, diamonds, single-chain silicates, and it is probably good for most other minerals.  Also, we can do localized microprobe analyses.  It is not as good as other methods for trace elements, but appears to work well for the major elements.  It provides rich compositional information at very fine resolution. 

   Questions: Rhonda Stuart, Naval Research Lab

            The geometry of Kilauea volcano's summit magma storage reservoir: A geochemical probe.  Aaron Pietruska, Department of Terrestrial Magnetism, Carnegie Institution of Washington:

   One of the most important components of the magmatic plumbing system of Kilauea Volcano is the shallow (2-4 km deep) magma storage reservoir that underlies the volcano’s summit region and supplies magma to the East Rift Zone where recent eruptions have occurred. 

   Nevertheless, the geometry (shape and size) of Kilauea’s summit reservoir is controversial.  Two fundamentally different models for the reservoir’s shape have been proposed based on geophysical observations:  a plexus of dikes and sills versus a single, "spherical" magma body.  Furthermore, the size of the reservoir is poorly constrained with estimates ranging widely from 0.08 to 40 km3.

   Temporal variations of Pb, Sr, and Nd isotope and incompatible trace element (e.g., La/Yb and Nb/Y) ratios of Kilauea’s historical summit lavas (1790-1982) were used to probe the geometry of the volcano’s summit reservoir.  These lavas preserve a nearly continuous, 200-year record of the changes in the composition of the parental magma supplied to the volcano.  Inferring reservoir volume from these data is possible because magma reaching the reservoir from below does not have constant composition.  Changes in lava composition at the surface depend on the changing composition of supplied magma, but also on the volume and geometry of the magma reservoir.  A large reservoir having a simple geometry, for example, would act as an effective buffer to reduce fluctuations in lava composition.  In a reservoir having a complex geometry, other factors such as the part of the reservoir currently releasing magma complicate the picture.  

   The systematic temporal variations in lava chemistry at Kilauea since the early 19th century suggest that the shape of the volcano’s summit reservoir is relatively simple.  Residence time analysis of these rapid geochemical fluctuations indicates that the volume of magma in Kilauea’s summit reservoir is only ~2-3 km3, which is smaller than most geophysical estimates (2-40 km3).

   This discrepancy can be explained if the volume calculated from lava chemistry represents the hotter, molten core of the reservoir in which magma mixing occurs, whereas the volumes estimated from geophysical data also include portions of the reservoir¹s outer crystal-mush zone and a hot, ductile region that surrounds the reservoir.  Although the volume estimate is small, the amount of magma stored within Kilauea’s summit reservoir since the early 19th century is an order of magnitude larger than the magma body supplying Piton de la Fournaise Volcano, another frequently active ocean-island volcano.

   Questions:  Bill Melson, Dick Fiske, George Helz

   Attendance was 57.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:55 PM.

   Respectfully Submitted,

   Mark McBride, Meeting Secretary

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1330th Meeting, Wednesday, May 10, 2000

Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 8:00 PM. 

   The minutes of the 1329th meeting were accepted as read.

   Visitors consisted of Sue Webb, University of Witwatersrand, South Africa; Don Palmer; and Chris Barton, USGS, St. Petersburg, Florida. 

   Four announcements were made:

   One new member, Edith Alison, was announced.

   A special AGU session was announced by Katherine Johnson.

   The spring field trip will be this Saturday.

   A moment of silence was observed in recognition of the death of Dave Gottfried.  He was a member of GSW from 1952 into the 1970s. 

   There were no informal communications.

   There were, as usual, three talks:

   Squeezed out or sucked in?  Characterizing melt flow in the anatectic zone.  Nathalie Marchildon, University of Maryland

   Ms. Marchildon addressed the basic question of segregation and migration in partly melted crust; in other words, how is a felsic melt exported upward from zones of melting deep in the crust?

   She presented field and petrological observations on the nature of layer-parallel leucosomes [the light-colored patches, in other words] in late-tectonic migmatites in the contact aureole of the Onawa pluton, central Maine, and used the observations to constrain a model for the formation of these leucosomes by deformation-controlled melt segregation during anatexis. Observations include: 1) the preferred position of layer-parallel leucosomes near or at contacts between graded sedimentary beds; 2) the presence of symmetric melanosomes [the dark patches] adjacent to leucosome layers; 3) evidence for asymmetric inflation of leucosomes by melt; 4) wide variability in leucosome modal mineralogy; 5) the similarity of plagioclase compositions and zoning trends in leucosomes and adjacent mesosomes; 6) quartz and plagioclase clusters in mesosome aligned parallel to the axial surface of regular folds of the layers; 7) symmetric alkali element depletion trends in mesosomes adjacent to layer-parallel leucosomes, not necessarily balanced by alkali element enrichment in the leucosome; 8) textural evidence indicating that melt was involved in leucosome formation. 

   Based on these observations, she proposes a model for layer-parallel leucosome formation by differential stress-driven melt segregation from less competent, mica-rich layers, to more competent quartzo-felspathic layers, leading to layer inflation by melt inflow, rather than segregation of melt in shear or tensile structures. [This seems to mean that the soft stuff gets squeezed out of the weak parts of the melted rock and into the stronger parts.]  Syn-anatectic contractional folds in part controlled the patterns of melt migration to the leucosomes.  Variable proportions of unmelted material initially present in the leucosome layers, of melt added to these layers and minerals crystallized from this melt, and of melt lost from the layers to external sinks explain the variability in layer-parallel leucosome compositions in these rocks.

   Questions by Jane Hammarstrom, Bill Burton, and Cy Galvin. 

   The effects of recharge, geologic setting, and regional water use on groundwater flow:  A case study at Dover Air Force Base, Delaware. Kurt Hinaman, U.S. Geological Survey, Delaware

   Hydrogeological investigations at Dover Air Force Base, Delaware have centered on the unconsolidated sediments of the coastal plain, mainly the surficial aquifer and the uppermost confined aquifer, the Frederica aquifer.  In the surficial aquifer, which consists of sands and gravels, there are local water-table highs with large (1.5m) vertical head gradients. These highs form above localized clay lenses which impede downward movement of groundwater.  Numerical simulations show that ground water flows horizontally from the local water-table highs and then vertically into the lower surficial aquifer. They also indicate that the direction of some of the horizontal flow from the local water-table high can be opposite from that in the lower surficial aquifer. 

   Continuous recorders on wells and surface water bodies show the effects of irrigation and of off-Base mining of sands and gravels. In the southern part of the base, hydrographs of water levels in the Frederica aquifer show that irrigation south of the base lowers the potentiometric surface in this aquifer to about 1.5 m below sea level.  West of the base, the sediments of the surficial aquifer are mined for sand and gravel.  A dredge mines from one pond a slurry of water, sand, and gravel.  This slurry is sent to a processing plant, where the sand and gravel are separated from the slurry and the water is discharged into a different pond.  Dredging can produce differences in level of as much as 4 m between nearby ponds.  Hydrographs of the water levels of the ponds and of water levels in adjacent wells show that a 3 meter change in the surface-water level results in about a 2 meter change in the water table at wells about 100 meters from the pond.  Numerical simulations of this mining shows that near the boundary of Dover Air Force Base, this mining can reverse the water-table gradient.

   Additional problems being investigated include chlorinated solvents and fuels in groundwater..

   Questions by Bill Burton, E-an Zen, and Dallas Peck.

            Hotspots, earthquakes, and the evolution of the Yellowstone volcanic system. Robert Smith, University of Utah

   The Yellowstone area is a great volcanic plateau.  Violent forces accompanying its active geological processes have produced the magnificent scenery of two of America's most popular national parks –  Yellowstone's geysers and hot springs, and Grand Teton's spectacular mountains.  These features are the result of two primary causes – the Yellowstone hotspot and stretching of Earth's crust as part of the Basin and Range extension.  Extension, coupled with rising magma, causes uplift and periodic eruptions.

   Earlier activity associated with the hotspot was formerly to the northeast of Yellowstone.  Hundreds of giant silicic volcanic eruptions from the Yellowstone hotspot destroyed mountains of southern Idaho during the past 16.5 million years, covering them with what is now the Snake River Plain volcanic field.  Later, as the North American Plate moved northeastward over the hotspot, three of these super eruptions, interspersed with hundreds of smaller eruptions, destroyed mountains that extended across Yellowstone, reshaping its topography during the past 2 million years.  One, about 630,000 years ago, was particularly catastrophic, ejecting 240 cubic miles of material and covering much of the western United States. 

   Energy and magma from the hotspot drives Yellowstone as a living, breathing volcano; produces frequent earthquakes, powers the park's famed geysers, uplifts and drops the ground by meters, refills its crustal magma reservoir, and creates a thermal flux in excess of 30 times the continental average.  The same forces also uplifted the spectacular Teton Range accompanied by thousands of large prehistoric earthquakes and dropping the valley of Jackson Hole along the Teton normal fault. The entire region was affected by extensive glaciation during the Pleistocene ice age, amplified by hotspot tumescence, and most recently by stream erosion that put the finishing touches on the scenery of Yellowstone and the Tetons. 

   Societally, we must consider the odds of future earthquakes and volcanic eruptions and manage these lands based on realistic scenarios of such disasters.

   Questions by Moto Sato, Jamie Allen, Bill Burton, and George Helz.

   Attendance was 64.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:50 PM.

   Respectfully Submitted,

   Mark McBride, Meeting Secretary

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1331st Meeting, Wednesday, September 6, 2000, Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 8:00 PM. 

   The minutes of the 1330th meeting were accepted as read.

   Visitors consisted of: Andrea Johnson, Joint Oceanographic Institutions; Roberta Rudnick, University of Maryland; Bruce Campbell, Air and Space Museum; Forrest Pike, Bureau of Energy and Minerals, Jeffry Burns, National Research Council; Ione Taylor, USGS Reston; and Al Taylor, independent oil and gas explorationist.

   Five announcements were made:

   We would like members to help recruit new members – particularly focusing on students and members of AAPG.

   Thanks to Mike Wise and Bill Burton for the excellent field trip to the Moorfield Pegmatite last spring.  Photos of this trip are at the back of the room and on GSW’s web site.

   The fall field trip will be Saturday, October 21st.  It will be in the DC area (exact location not yet set), and is intended as a memorial to Jim O’Connor.

   Teachers at Mann Elementary School are looking for resources to help 6th graders construct a geological time line of the DC area.  Who can help them?

   Earth Science week is coming up. 

   There was one informal communication by Jane Hammarstrom.  She described her summer field work on the Salmon River, Idaho.  A forest fire near Stanley, Idaho enlivened the activities.  She was looking for the environmental signature of mines along the Salmon River.  Effects of mining on the river may be significant if dams along the river are removed, possibly releasing contaminated sediments.  Her route followed, in part, the footsteps of John Wesley Powell’s 1869 expedition.  In particular, it included a stop at a park in Green River, Wyoming, where Powell set off from Expedition Island to explore western rivers. 

   There were three formal presentations:

   A Quaternary history of aeolian sediment mobilization in the Sahara.  Chris Swezey, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston

   The Sahara desert is not composed entirely of sand dunes.  Fluvial and lacustrine sediments were observed in the Sahara during the 19th century, and were later shown to be Holocene in age.  These appear to be related to millennial-scale climatic changes.  It was believed, however, that aeolian systems responded on much longer time scales. 

   Swezey’s research investigated these issues.  He worked in the area of the Chott Rharsa, a playa located in western Tunisia.  This area contains diverse depositional environments.  Moving southward from the Chott Rharsa, one encounters salt flat, grading into an erosional zone, areas of recent windblown sand moving across an old deflation surface, and into the sand sea of the Grand Erg Oriental, where sand is now accumulating. 

   Thermoluminescence dating of quartz grains showed that a thick sedimentary section in the area, which included interbedded lacustrine deposits as well as aeolian sands, had been deposited within the last 15,000 years.  The Chott Rharsa record and earlier aeolian strata fit fairly well with previously established Saharan stratigraphy, and show millennial-scale responses to climatic influences

   Questions:  Dan Milton, Jan Hammarstrom, Moto Sato, and Suzanne Weidman. 

   Experimental evidence on the behavior of gold in magmatic-hydrothermal systems.  Mark Frank, University of Maryland

   Frank’s research centers on simulating conditions within hydrothermal systems that contribute to gold transport and deposition.  He began by looking at conditions inferred from the Ginzberg Complex, a very large and rich porphyry gold deposit in Irian Jaya, Indonesia.  The temperature of brines involved in gold deposition was probably more than 600 degrees C, and salinity more than 58 weight %.  He designed experiments to simulate these conditions. 

   The experimental brine was 70% concentration, and consisted of NaCl + KCl + HCl + H20.  The melt was granitic in composition.  Experiments were conducted at a temperature of 800 degrees C and a pressure of 100 MPA.  The materials were enclosed in a gold capsule, which also served as the source of dissolved gold.  Each experimental run included two capsules, one brine-rich and one brine-poor.  The resulting glass was analyzed using neutron irradiation analysis for Au and Cl, and electron microprobe for major elements. 

   Results showed that inclusion-rich glasses were elevated in Au and Cl.  Au was much enriched when Cl was greater than 10,000 ppm in the brine.  It was concluded that gold was transported in the brine as chloride complexes, as AuCl at chloride concentrations less than 10,000 ppm, and AuCl2 at greater concentrations. 

   Questions: Jane Hammarstrom, one unidentified, Moto Sato, and Pete Toulmin.

   From Boundaries to Barrels - Sequence Stratigraphy and Oil Potential, North Slope, Alaska.  David Houseknecht, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston

   Sequence stratigraphy is being applied successfully to oil exploration on the North Slope of Alaska.  Sequence stratigraphy is based on the recognition of packages of sediments that are enclosed within boundary surfaces, which are unconformities and their correlative conformities. 

   The emphasis in oil exploration on the North Slope has changed over time.  During the 1970s, emphasis was on giant fields in older rocks.  In the 1980s, emphasis shifted to deepwater giant fields in younger strata.  In the late 1980s and early 1990s, more work was done on deepwater structural and stratigraphic traps.  Since than, there has been interest in onshore and shallow water structural traps in younger rocks. 

   Recently there has been a focus on the Upper Jurassic Kingiak Shale.  Coring of buried strata known only from seismic exploration shows a condensed section to the south, and muddy sand to the north.  Looking at this section in sequence stratigraphic terms suggests that seismic reflectors correspond to sequence boundaries.  Sands deposited at highstand are shore facies that form the reservoir rock. 

   Another play currently of interest is turbidites discovered just outside the NPRA.  These are deep-water deposits from the rising Brooks Range, deposited into a foreland basin.  This looks like a promising area for exploration.

   Applying sequence stratigraphic principles to these new plays appears to be promising.  The challenge now is to figure out the controls on sediment deposition. 

   Questions: Dallas Peck

   Attendance was 76.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:35 PM.

   Respectfully Submitted,

   Mark McBride, Meeting Secretary

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1332nd Meeting, Wednesday, September 20, 2000, Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 8:01 PM. 

   The minutes of the 1331st meeting were accepted as revised.  It was noted that the guest identified in the minutes as Robert Redneck was most likely Dr. Roberta Rudnick of the University of Maryland.  [Of course, this was fixed in the version of the minutes submitted to the Archivist. –MSM]

   Visitors consisted of Andy MUMBLE, Mumble McDaniel, Mumble McSack, Al Taylor from Nomad Geosciences, Robert Brand of SAIC, and Jim Hayes of Jack Faucett Associates.

   Seven new members were announced: Christopher Swezey, Roberta Rudnick, Carl Smith, Christopher Smith, Horace Pipe, Jim Hayes and William McDonough.  Earth Science Week and the October 21 Field trip to the Mall (lead by Ray Rye and Norrie Robbins) were announced.

   Cy Galvin presented an informal communication on James Hutton and Granite. Cy’s point was that to Hutton many rock types including many sedimentary rocks like salt, flint and coal were the result of rock “fusion” or melting.  Granite was relatively little discussed in Hutton’s writing, and where it was mentioned it also appears to have been considered the result of melting. An additional point therefore was that the mythology and legend around Hutton frequently obscure his actual writings.

The three presentations this evening were a delightful digression from convoluted isotopic distributions, innumerable elegant but opaque thin sections, and turgid organizational euphemisms. They can be summed up as the myriad pleasures, pitfalls and pratfalls of trying to do geology with the aid of  intelligence agents as helpers, large armored vehicles and exploding drill core.

   A Trip to the Jade Mines of Nansibon, Myanmar (Burma).  Sorena Sorensen, National Museum of Natural History

   The first presentation was a cultural tour-de-force describing how you collect jadeitite samples from conglomerate deposits, which are not located on the available topographic maps of 1919, the geologic maps from 1934, nor where your GPS receivers tell you that YOU are. This past summer’s expedition tested soil moisture with Land Cruisers on the jungle trek to the Nansibon mines in northern Myanmar.  14 Military intelligence helpers in traditional dress and with cell phones contributed to the success of the five geologists who made this foray by explaining to the local population why these non-Englishmen stayed out in the noon-day sun anyway.  The bedrock jadeitite dikes that were the expedition’s original objective were inaccessible for political reasons. The Nansibon mine workings were deep cuts through sedimentary conglomeratic deposits, where even with power shovels for excavating, the bulk of the work separating the jadeitite cobbles was done by individuals with rakes.  The cobbles were in a largely serpentinitic matrix and both cobbles and matrix were presumed to have been eroded from upland metamorphic terrains nearby (probably to the west).  The locals were much more successful at finding jadeitite samples than the scientists so the latter fell back on the fisherman’s solution of buying their catch rather than catching their own. The specimens are currently under examination.

   Questions by Peck, Zen, Ross, Sato and Robertson.

   An Army Geologist: War Stories for Insomniacs.  John Jens, Army Corps of Engineers

   John got his start in the Army with 30 ton tracked and armored vehicles and then moved on to the engineers.  He has written such heart-stopping military classics as FM-5-105 Manual on Topographic Operations and some less widely reprinted works, such as a book on Environmental Trends with the Council on Environmental Quality. His primary Corps of Engineers responsibility has been in training army personnel to appreciate what understanding geology can contribute to their primary objectives of building some things and destroying others. His work with the Defense Mapping Agency, and his work with the Corps on Terrain Analysis methods, Water Supply-Flood Control issues, and the Army’s Urban Tactical Planner program has all been aimed at utilizing geospatial information systems and linking them with military users, ideally in real time.  He has evolved from using tracked armored vehicles as soil moisture sensors to using passive microwave aerial mapping; the latter has the values of greater resolution and less collateral damage.    

   One question by Mumble.

   Recent Climate Data, Siple Dome, West Antarctica.  Christopher Shuman, University of Maryland (ESSIC) and NASA

   Willie Sutton went to banks because that’s where the money was and Dr. Shuman goes where the ice is, Greenland and West Antarctica.  This talk concerned ice core drilling on an inter-stream area between two West Antarctic ice streams. The ice streams may move up to 700 meters/year.  Rapid ice sheet calving at the shore downstream from Siple Dome related to global climate changes may allow even more rapid drainage of the upland ice caps through the Siple Dome area in the future.  This is a mobile drilling program that cores ice to a depth of roughly 200 feet in order to evaluate the relatively recent history of the West Antarctic ice sheet by reconstructing precipitation, isotopic trends to index summer and winter seasonality, and by reconstructing the temperature record recorded by the ice through current observations, pit investigations and the deeper coring.  There are potential problems in the core drilling programs in various parts of Antarctica however, including for the French and Dutch drilling teams which got their tools stuck in their holes, and the Americans whose cores tended to explode from exsolving gases when removed from the core barrels. The overall objective is to reconstruct Antarctic and global temperature trends over the last 200 years. Data collected so far suggests that surface measurements, pit measurements and core measurements record the precipitation and temperature records consistently and reproducibly allowing firm inferences on those variables over the last several hundred years.

   Questions by Burton, Zen, Peck, Sato, Jones, Robertson, Burton again, Peck again, and Taylor.

   Attendance was 67.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:56 PM.

   Respectfully Submitted,

   Emergency Backup Secretary,

   Nick Woodward for Mark McBride, Meeting Secretary

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1333rd Meeting, Wednesday, October 11th, 2000, Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 8:00 PM. 

   The minutes of the 1332nd meeting on September 20th were taken by Nick Woodward, in the absence of the Secretary.  By a complex chain of events, however, the President forgot to bring them to the meeting.  The members, no doubt aware of the length of some of the Secretary’s earlier minutes, enthusiastically accepted them as unread.

   Visitors consisted of Katy Makeig, this year’s American Geological Institute Congressional Fellow; Mathias Bartz, of Harvard University; and Bill McDonough, of the University of Maryland. 

   Two announcements were made:

   Bill Burton reminded everyone of the field trip on October 21st.  The trip will meet at the Museum of Natural History at 1:00 to examine building stones and geomorphology of the Washington Mall.

   Sally Newcomb announced several field trips and other events to be held at next year’s GSA in Boston.  These include a walking tour around Boston; a topical session on biogeography; a “Boston to Buffalo” transect in honor of Amos Eaton; and a session on ophiolites.

   There was one informal communication.  Dave Applegate read President Clinton’s proclamation of Earth Science Week.  The audience rejected a request for a one-minute rebuttal. 

            Magmatic Underplating in the Ivrea-Verbano Zone, northwestern Italian Alps.  James Quick, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston

   During the 1980s, it became clear that magmatic underplating is a significant phenomenon.  Magmatic underplating consists of ponding of melts at the crust-mantle boundary, often producing layered bodies of magmatic rock.  Quick’s research aimed at studying an example in the field, to see how deep intrusions form.  This area selected is located along the junction between the Italian plate and the European plate.  Large mafic intrusions were known to intrude Jurassic crustal rocks, but the very steep mountainous area, about 8 x 30 km, had never been properly mapped.  During the Alpine orogeny, the mafic intrusion was shattered but little deformed; apparently, the area represented a section of the deep crust.  Migmatites form the top of the section, and grade downward into layered basalts.  Extreme stretching is shown, for example, by the presence of paragneiss septa as much as 15 km long but only from 1 to 10 m wide.  The section formed in an extension zone, similar to the modern Salton Sea.  Melt from the mantle intruded the extension zone.  The volume of melt was not large, since it formed only a small aureole.  Evidently, crustal material was deformed downward into the magmatic crystal mush, and stretched to form an arcuate deformed zone.  The conclusion is that the study area represents a big lens or boudin – the mantle is not exposed, and so the area is, in fact, a bad example of crustal underplating. 

   Questions: Bill Burton, Moto Sato, Dan Milton, Roz Helz, Mike Brown. 

            Global warming and sea level: A different view.  S. Fred Singer, Science and Environmental Policy Project

   Dr. Singer’s hypothesis is that the earth’s climate is not now warming.  His position is described in his new book, Hot Talk – Cold Science.  There is no question, he thinks, that the greenhouse effect is real – but reliable data show that the atmosphere is not warming.  Which should be believe? Available data show a mixed picture, but overall suggest that no warming is occurring.  Surface data show warming from 1880 to 1940, then cooling until about 1970, followed by warming.  Overall, this probably represents recovery from the Little Ice Age.  But, radiosonde and microwave sounding measurements show no warming at higher elevations.  This disparity is still a puzzle, but likely represents problems with the surface temperature measurements.  Global temperature data show a warming trend, but data from the US show no warming.  US data have, however, been carefully treated to remove urban heat island effects.  Therefore, it is likely that urban effects have contaminated the global temperature data set.  Temperatures measured in Greenland ice cores show no warming after 1945.  Melting of terrestrial glaciers is inconclusive.  Glaciers started melting during 1850 – 1900.  Some continue to melt, but others do not; and none are melting at an accelerating rate.  It is true that arctic ice is shrinking, but this is because of pre-1940 warming, since it is warmer today than 100 years ago.  Warming has been observed in deep ocean water, but this is the result of convection of water warmed before 1940.  Sea level is rising at about 18 cm per century.  However, melting has continued since the melting of the continental ice sheets, and will probably continue for about the next 5,000 years, being driven mostly by the melting of the West Antarctic ice sheet. 

   Questions: Cy Galvin, Chris Swezey, Fred Brooks. 

            Origin of orbicular structures in Devonian granites near East Bethel, Vermont, revealed.  Nicholas Ratcliffe, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston

   Orbicular structures, consisting of spheres of biotite and muscovite in granites, were noted as early as the 1850s, when thy were described as “butternuts” or “walnuts”.  The kind discussed here consist of micaceous crystals surrounding a granite core.  In the East Bethel area, granites intruded into schist about 370 to 390 my, forming two granite bodies surrounded by a chill zone.  In outcrop, we find rounded to subrounded fragments of country rock incorporated into the granite.  Orbicules have an onion-like structure of mica crystals, with a few K-spar crystals that enclose or occur within the micas.  Often, orbicules have a similar orientation.  Orbicules are found in dikes, and attached to the schist wall rock.  Schist forms projections into the granite, and various stages of separation of orbicules from wall rock can be observed.  Also, biotite appears in some cases to have been forced outward by growing crystals.  The conclusion is that, when the orbicules were formed, the granite and the schist had a similar degree of ductility, so that pieces of schist easily separated from the wall rock.  Poikilitic crystals formed inside orbicules by exchange with the outside.  Orbicules thus formed largely by physical, not chemical, processes at locations where there was shearing along the contact between granite and schist. 

   Questions: Cy Galvin, Bill Burton

   Attendance was 73.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:52 PM.

   Respectfully Submitted,

   Mark McBride, Meeting Secretary

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1334rd Meeting, Wednesday, November 8th, 2000, Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 8:00 PM. 

   The minutes of the 1333rd meeting were accepted as read.

   Visitors consisted of David Norman, Cambridge University; Chris Elfring, Polar Research Board, National Academy of Sciences; Pei Ling Wang, Academica Sinica, Taiwan; and Suzy and Jim Smith.

   Three announcements were made:

   Members were reminded to send in their dues payments.

   The deaths of Dave Davidson, of the U.S. Geological Survey, and G. Arthur Cooper were announced.  Cooper was GSW President in 1961. He was the last chairman of the Department of Geology at the National Museum, and the first chairman of the Department of Paleobiology.  A moment of silence observed.

   President Hammarstrom expressed the Society’s thanks for a successful fall field trip, which was attended by 36 people.  The trip, covering primarily the geomorphology and building stones of the Washington Mall, was organized by Ray Rye, Karen Gray, Norrie Robbins, and Bruce Doe. 

   The slate of officers for the next year was announced, as follows:

President: Peter Lyttle, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston*

1st Vice President (2000) & President-Elect (2001): Nicholas Woodward, Dept. of Energy

2nd Vice-President: Sandra Neuzil, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston

Treasurer: Louis Pribyl, U.S. Department of Agriculture

Meeting Secretary: John Hanchar, George Washington University

Council Secretary: Mark McBride, Capital Environmental*

Continuing Councilors (2000-2001):*

     Amelia Logan, U.S. Geological Survey

     Steve Huebner, independent

     Suzanne Weedman, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston

New Councilors (2001-2002):

     Cy Galvin, Coastal Engineer

     Allan Kolker, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston

     Nathalie Marchildon, University of Maryland

Note: * denotes officers and councilors carrying over from 2000.

   There was one informal communication.  Ellis Yochelson described an apparent fossil from the Middle Proterozoic that may be of use as an index fossil.  It has been observed in finely laminated fine siltstones of the Lower Apacuni Formation (?spelling?) near the east edge of Glacier National Park.  The fossils appears as rows or strings of bumps with halos, each a few millimeters across.  The individuals (?) have the shapes of tiny ice cream cones.  They appear to be connected, possibly by a tube, as shown by their remaining together and making tool marks on the bedding surfaces during transportation.  They may represent early metazoans.  Similar fossils have been observed in Australia in rocks more than 1GY, and have been traced in these rocks for more than 400 km along the outcrop.  Questions: Dallas Peck, Moto Sato

   There were three formal communications:

            Glaciology Research at the Bottom of the World: Ice Sheets, Ice Streams and Icebergs.  Julie Palais, National Science Foundation Antarctic Glaciology Program

   Ms. Palais discussed research supported by the Antarctic Glaciology Program in the Office of Polar Programs at the National Science Foundation (NSF).  NSF is the lead agency for all U.S. research conducted in Antarctica.  The Antarctic Glaciology Program supports research related to the history and dynamics of the Antarctic ice sheet, including studies of paleoclimate from ice cores, ice sheet modeling, snow-atmosphere-ice interactions, glacial geology, among other topics. The program operates three permanent bases: McMurdo, Amundson-Scott (at the South Pole), and Palmer Station on the Palmer Peninsula.

   The West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) Program is a major activity of the program.  Its goal is to predict the ice sheet's future behavior by developing an understanding of its history, current state, internal dynamics and its coupling to the current global climate.  The main focus of the WAIS research in recent years has been the study of the ice streams which drain West Antarctica along the Siple Coast onto the Ross Ice Shelf. 

   Other areas of active research supported by the Antarctic Glaciology Program include studies of paleoclimate from ice cores.  Some examples include work on the deep Vostok ice core, the Siple Dome ice core and the Taylor Dome ice core.   A related program is the International Trans-Antarctic Scientific Expedition (ITASE) which is making over-snow traverses and collecting shallow snow and ice samples in order to determine recent mass balance, the impact of anthropogenic activity and the variability of climate over the last 200 years.

   New research programs this year include the study of the large icebergs in the Ross Sea near McMurdo Station and a site survey of Lake Vostok, a large, recently discovered subglacial lake in East Antarctica.  The former will provide information to scientists who are interested in understanding the factors which affect the movement of these large icebergs, one of which was 295 km long and 37 km wide.  The site survey of Lake Vostok will provide the basic boundary conditions which will help in the formulation of a science and implementation plan for a future international program of in-situ exploration of Lake Vostok.  The lake provides an example of extreme conditions for possible life, and might be an analog for the oceans inferred to exist on Europa. 

Questions: Jane Hammarstrom, Moto Sato, E-an Zen, Chris Neuzil, Dallas Peck, and Ray Rye.

            The origin of modern terrestrial ecosystems: a fossil lagerstaette from the Triassic of Virginia and North Carolina.  Nick Fraser, Virginia Museum of Natural History

   The Triassic period was pivotal for development of modern terrestrial fauna.  At its beginning were primitive animals like aetosaurs, and lots of other odd (and old) creatures.  By its end more modern forms like frogs and crocodiles had originated, as had the dinosaurs. 

   During the Triassic, the Newark Supergroup was deposited mostly in half-grabens formed during the rifting of Pangaea.  Tracks from these rocks are well known, but few body fossils have been found. 

   A newly discovered fossil lagerstaette from the Newark Supergroup sheds new light on the fauna of the Triassic.  This is located in a large quarry on the North Carolina-Virginia border, which has produced thousands of specimens of body fossils.  These include plant fossils, and a lizard-like aquatic creature with traces of soft tissues, and more than 3,000 insects.  It is considered the world’s best site for Triassic insects.  Specimens are generally from 1 to 10 mm long, and are excellently preserved.  Those found include caddis flies, thrips, beetles, flies, and water bugs.  Many are similar to modern forms.  Spiders are also present – these are the oldest spiders known. The depositional environment is unclear.  Apparently it was a shallow lacustrine environments, possibly in an alkaline lake, since there has been no bioturbation caused by bottom-feeding organisms.  The mix of archaic and modern forms found provides a valuable window into a pivotal period. 

   Questions: Dan Milton, E-an Zen, Bob Burrus.

            Sedimentary stratigraphy at the bottom, middle, and top of the Earth's magma ocean.  William Minarik, University of Maryland

Differentiated meteorites, Lunar and Martian samples, and modeling of accretion of the earth all suggest that there was enough thermal energy present late in the accretion process to melt a large portion of the Earth’s mantle.  Evidence for this “magma ocean” has, however, been difficult to document. 

   One way to approach this issue is by way of trace elements.  Rare earth elements partition differently into different minerals vs melt according to the depth.  At high pressures, greater than about 25 GPA, the mineralogy of silicates becomes relatively simple.  There are only two principal minerals, perovskite (in a high-pressure octohedral form), and magnesiowüstite.  The lower mantle is believed to consist largely of these minerals. 

   If the magma ocean occurred, it might have been well mixed, or else it might have settled into layers according to density.  If such layering occurred, we can, in principle, test for it and thus infer the existence of the magma ocean.  The effect of layering would be an isotopic signature which is the ultimate result of elemental partitioning between the magma and minerals that crystallized from it. 

   Equilibration of various elements between the melt and perovskite is of particular interest.  Suitable pairs of elements for comparison are Nd/Sm, Lu/Hf, and Re/Os.  Perovskite is unstable at the surface, but we can look for isotopic evidence in suitable samples from the deep mantle (for example, hot-spot lavas) to allow us to infer the existence of perovskite, and thus the existence of mantle layering.  Suitable isotope pairs are Nd143/Nd144, Hf176/Hf177, and Os 187/Os188.

   Elemental partition coefficients between melt and minerals must be determined experimentally.  Early evidence against the existence of a magma ocean was provided by experiments carried out about 12 years ago.  These indicated that perovskite would not have occurred in the lower mantle. 

   Recent experiments at the Carnegie Institute using the multi-anvil press at pressures of 27 GPA (i.e. representing the lower mantle) showed elemental partition coefficients slightly different than those from the earlier experiments.  These new results, combined with isotope ratios from the literature, allow the existence of up to 5% perovskite in the lower mantle, but still allow rocks with the observed compositions.  These results do not prove the existence of the magma ocean, but at least allow for its existence. 

   Attendance was 56.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:48 PM.

   Respectfully Submitted,

   Mark McBride, Meeting Secretary

 

Geological Society of Washington

Minutes of the 1335th Meeting, Wednesday, December 6th, 2000

Powell Auditorium, Cosmos Club

   President Hammarstrom called the meeting to order at 8:00 PM. 

   The minutes of the 1334th meeting were accepted as read.

   Visitors consisted of:

            Michiko Saito, Tokyo University

            Kirsten Cutler, AGU Congressional Fellow, and her husband Paul from the University of Wisconsin

            Renato Moraes, University of Brazilia, Brazil

            Bruce Simonson, Oberlin College

            Bob Tucker and Julie Morris, Carnegie

            John Wormington, Montana Tech, Butte, Montana

   No announcements were made, and there were no informal communications.

            Presidential Address: Metals, mines, and Mother Nature: The solid story of acid rock drainage.  Jane Hammarstrom, U.S. Geological Survey, Reston, VA

   Acid rock drainage is the water-quality hazard produced by oxidation of pyrite. When the pyrite is in a mine, the term acid mine drainage (AMD) is used.  The pH of such drainage is typically in the range 2 to 4.  Acid drainage can also occur when pyrite-bearing lithologies are exposed to weathering, be it natural or exacerbated by construction activities or when fresh surfaces are exposed by landslides. 

   Weathering of iron- and other metal sulfide minerals produces suites of variably soluble secondary sulfate minerals.  These secondary minerals include efflorescent sulfate salts and ochres. Many of the salts, such as the iron sulfate minerals melanterite and rozenite, form on outcrops or mine tailings during dry spells and temporarily sequester metals and acidity.  Dissolution of these highly soluble minerals contributes pulses of metals and acidity to surface runoff.  Ochres include iron oxyhydroxide and hydroxysulfate minerals such as ferrihydrite, goethite, schwertmannite, and jarosite.  The particular ochre mineral that forms depends on local pH and dissolved sulfate concentrations.  Ochres are important because they tend to sorb metals, and can play a role in self-mitigation.  pH is a master variable for sorption, and different metals tend to sorb in different pH ranges. Changes in pH over time can release previously sorbed metals to solution.

   In the Vermont copper belt and the Central Virginia Mineral Belt, jarosite and schwertmannite occur on mine tailings, and as precipitates in low pH (<4) surface waters.  Efflorescent sulfate salts form on tailings and outcrop surfaces; salts include highly soluble solid solutions that incorporate heavy metals, primarily minerals of the rozenite- and halotrichite-groups. Salt dissolution releases iron, which can be oxidized; undergo hydrolysis; and precipitate as hydrous ferric oxide or hydroxysulfate minerals, generating acidity in the process. 

   Ferrous sulfate salts are also observed in Great Smoky Mountains National Park where sulfide-bearing metamorphic rocks, undisturbed by mining, are exposed. Dissolution experiments on bulk salts from 3 mine sites and 2 metamorphic rock outcrops, in which 20 g of salt is dissolved in 400 mL DI water at pH 6.9, show that pH drops to <3.7 instantaneously, to <3.2 within 30 minutes and decreases slightly over 24 hours.  Solutions filtered after 24 hours show that all of the salts provide ready sources of dissolved Al (>30 mg/L), Fe (>47 mg/L), sulfate (>1,000 mg/L), and base metals (>1,000 mg/L for mine sites; 2 mg/L for other sites).

   Periodic surface water monitoring at mines sites indicated peak annual metal loads during spring runoff in Vermont.  At the Virginia site, where no winter-long snow pack develops, metal loads were highest during summer months when salts are flushed by rainstorms following dry spells.  The role of salts in acid drainage is well-documented in arid and semi-arid settings, and in some coal fields.  Despite the relatively humid climate of the eastern U.S., where precipitation typically exceeds evaporation, salts form intermittently in open areas and persist in protected areas when appropriate temperature and relative humidity conditions prevail; salt dissolution contributes to metal loadings and acidity in surface waters and causes short-term perturbations in water quality.

   Salts form in a variety of geologic setting in the relatively humid climate of the eastern U.S.  They represent readily soluble sources of iron, aluminum (especially toxic to fish), metals, and acidity.  Long-term water quality monitoring is necessary to document seasonal variations in surface water quality to develop effective mine site reclamation plans.  Jarosite is common in ochres associated with weathering of massive sulfide deposits (in contrast to coal mines where schwertmannite is the more typical iron hydroxysulfate mineral).  Ochres sequester base metals to a greater extent at higher pH, as predicted by sorption models.  Ochres associated with near-neutral seep areas may serve as local sinks for zinc and play a role in natural mitigation.  Secondary minerals form by evaporation, oxidation, dilution, mixing, or neutralization and are effective at recycling metals and acidity in surface environments.  Mineralogy is the key to understanding acid rock drainage.

   Attendance was ­­­­73.  President Hammarstrom adjourned the meeting at 9:15 PM.

   Respectfully Submitted,

   Mark McBride, Meeting Secretary